Which Is Best: Pilates Or Yoga
Both yoga and Pilates are intended to build strength and more fit and to sharpen flexibility and coordination. Both practices use postures and matwork to accomplish these goals. But, there are fundamental differences in the ways that yoga and Pilates seek to accomplish these goals.
Highly disciplined movements are a part of both arrangements, though the actions have noticeably different executions. In yoga, the principle purpose is an spiritual improvement, such as finding peace. The outward movements are directed toward creating the the internal changes. The stances that are in yoga are concerned with breathing and the search for enlightenment. In Pilates, the stretches are not just on a floor mat, but are also performed with a pilates exercise machines. The center of this discipline is on the physical- to make the body stronger, tone and exercise precise muscles.
There are few items needed in yoga- usually just a sticky mat, a couple of small items and a yoga outfit. But, Pilates makes use of a machine called the reformer. This instrument is a needed item that emphasizes resistance in order to create flexibility and strength in the abdomen. The item exercises the whole body at once, using every major muscle group to perform the exercises.
In yoga, the movements are done to bring harmony to the mind and body. Many movements in yoga and movements involve a concentration on a few specific regions of the body. Pilates, however, focuses on the full body. Every area of the body is made stronger by the Pilates workout. The core, called the powerhouse in Pilates, is the main purpose of the exercises. While yoga concentrates on being still and calm, with stances held with a fixed concentration, Pilates focuses on movement. Making the powerhouse stronger, as well as other muscle groups, which leads to many changes in the physique.
Those who start practicing yoga are often seeking a spiritual harmony. Seeking a stronger relationship with God or with the entire universe is the primary mission of many of the yoga types. The meditation that takes place in yoga is take the practitioner out of the material world. While Pilates involves a a connection of the physical and metnal, the focus is primarily on the physical.
The Pilates exercise regimen was invented by one person- Joseph Pilates, and consists of specific exercises designed to create specific effects. But yoga has a much older history. The many yoga types in general are loose in their interpretation of how to practice them. The poses, chants and exercises are used in the best way for each person to reach their goals, rather than as a specific regimen.
Choosing between yoga or Pilates should involve assessing the overall goals of the routine. If there is a weight loss goal, or a goal to have toned abs and extra flexibility, Pilates is probably the proper choice. If the goal is to reduce stress and increase flexibility, yoga is probably the right choice. If you prefer a more predictable exercise routine with more predictable results, you may wish to choose Pilates. If you would prefer an exercise routine that will allow some variation of the exercises, you may wish to choose yoga. Both of these methods are low impact, and both result in increased stamina.
Filed under Health by on Feb 3rd, 2008.